The second major portion of the Environmental Impact Statement deals with transportation and traffic issues. It's fair to say that there are reasons to be concerned about real infrastructure stresses as people arrive before games and leave afterward. Some intersections in the warehouse district are predicted to be almost gridlocked unless changes are made between now and then. But this is not a surprise.
What did surprise me, and actually made my jaw drop, was this little nugget:
It should be noted that currently, there are no plans for the Northstar commuter rail service to be available for Ballpark events. Northstar commuter rail could become a great resource for transporting people to the game and reducing parking and traffic levels. However, for purposes of this analysis, zero percent of the Ballpark patrons were assumed to utilize the Northstar commuter rail. (EIS, page 45)
At first, I thought this might just be the safest assumption to make given the purpose of the document. But in the next section, there is a grid of possible changes which could be made to mitigate some of the anticipated traffic problems. Each possible change is rated with a general cost estimate, and a general estimate of the likelihood that it might happen. In that grid is the following:
The North Star Commuter rail service should be explored as another supplementary transit option. Currently, commuter rail would only operate during a.m. and p.m. peak hours to accommodate those working in downtown Minneapolis or transfer to LRT. This option might be dependent on the availability of commuter trains and available rail time. Cost: Moderate. Feasibility: Unlikely. (EIS, page 71)
So let me get this straight: Our brand new Urban Ballpark has been highly touted as becoming a perfect mass transit hub by being strategically located at the junction of two major passenger rail lines -- only there won't be any Northstar passenger trains after games. How stupid is this?
Surely there are Twins fans in Fridley, Coon Rapids, Anoka, Elk River, Big Lake and beyond, right? That's Twins Territory too, isn't it? Is there a better, easier, faster, and potentially cheaper way to get to the ballpark than taking a train which stops right on its doorstep? You only have to look at the completely packed light rail cars before and after games these days to know the answer to that question.
At left, across the tracks by that pile of dirt is where the Northstar commuter train platform will be built, and where Twins fans will apparently NOT be able to get a train after night games. (For reference, that's the Fifth Street bridge, with the ballpark site just beyond it. The east corner of Ford Centre is just visible at the right edge of the picture.)
Five trains will run from Big Lake to Minneapolis with one reverse trip during weekday mornings. During weekday afternoons & evenings five trains will run from Minneapolis to Big Lake with one reverse trip. Each weekend day, three roundtrips will be provided; as well as, possible special event service.
Millers fans leaving Nicollet Park after a game in 1923, where a trolley was waiting. (Click to enlarge.)
At least that leaves the door open.
I have to believe that this is some sort of political issue, and maybe the report included these statements just to make the point that the current plans are going to have to be changed. Much can and will change in the next three years, and I'm sure this isn't set in stone. Somewhere along the line this will probably get figured out.
But one way to hobble a new passenger rail line is to limit its flexibility (as was tried with the light rail line). And I know that there are still people in the Legislature who doubt the feasibility of commuter rail and are actively trying to kill this project (and several others like it which hover just off the radar). That could be what's at work behind the scenes, implied by the inclusion of this little nugget in the ballpark documents.
There is some comfort in the certainty that opponents of commuter rail will be mighty embarrassed one day about ever doubting these sure-to-succeed-beyond-anyone's-wildest-imagination projects.
That is if they can figure out how to get people home after games.
122 recent recognized visitors, including: antifire, ben, Chad, Dave, DeePee, Excited, Expectorate, F_T_K, FD, fiesta, gogotwins, grizzly adams, gus munger, J2k, Jared, Jay, jctwins, Joe117, Jorge, LC, luke, NotMendoza, ole, Stevie B, terry, Tom D., trebor651, Twinkfan, Uffda, Winona Mike
This page was last modified on January 21, 2010.
"You talk about the magic, the aura, but what really makes a stadium is the fans. Concrete doesn't talk back to you. Chairs don't talk back to you. It's the people who are there, day in, day out, that makes the place magic."
– Bernie Williams
Explore the Site
Here are 50 images chosen randomly from the 3042 found on this site. Click the image to be taken to the original post. A new list is created every 10 minutes.
The storage tunnel is barely visible at left behind that guy.
June 29,1936 - May 17, 2011
The louvres on Fifth have been completely filled in
This is an angle I have not used very much, from the top of the Fifth Street ramp. Because the wall is so tall (forget about watching a game from here for free -- OK, maybe with a step stool) I have to hold the camera up over my head and just snap, hoping I get something good. Here I did. This view then looks to the southwest.
B ramp at left, ballpark at right (and visible far away through the tiny crack)
Home Plate Box, Section 111, Row 8 or 9-ish (Click to enlarge greatly.)
Section 237, Row 15 (top of the Trap)
The view down Sixth Street toward the ballpark site. A pedestrian bridge will extend this street right into the main entrance of the park. The regrettable facade of Target Center is on the left. Butler Square is on the right. Click on the image to see what it looked like on this very spot about 100 years ago.
Ye Olde Tyme Vegetable Cart (and its modern cousin)
Location for automated ticket machines
Here is one of the concept drawings referenced (but not shown) in the MPR story (conceptual ballpark at left, LRT tracks switched to the north half of the Fifth Street bridge, which is actually in all of the long-range plans).
Mary Larson (left), a music teacher from Maple Grove, was a TwinsFest SSB winner and got to sing the anthem before the game.
Here's where I was when the alarm went off, and though the siren wasn't terribly loud, at least one guy is plugging his ears.
Artist at work
Such promise. (Click to enlarge.)
This looks up Sixth Street from Hennepin. Just imagine what this will look like during a night game!
The shade of the canopy gives way to a brief shaft of light. It would do the same again a short while later when the sun passed through that tiny open sliver between the View and Terrace levels.
Better them than me
Fun with section counting!
Bike parking available along Second Avenue
The green in question (click for very large version)
Here's the barricade in context at the end of the walkway
This design has a rather generic quality to it, but they appear to have considered the B garage. Though it isn't part of the model, they've clearly left room for it.
The Metropolitan Club (click to enlarge)
At the corner of the Pro Shop.
A final glimpse from the street of stadia installation along the left field line